What To Serve With Tomato Pie

Are you thinking of what to serve with tomato pie to round your meal off perfectly? If so, continue reading because we’ve rounded up the best side dishes to make this dish an unforgettable treat.

This Italian American pizza has a fascinating history linked to Sicilian pizza or “sfincione”. However, they are not the same. Baked with a focaccia-like dough, this dish has a thick texture and rich tomato sauce when you chew it. Oregano and Romano cheese are traditional tomato pie toppings. But there are several other toppings you could try. 

Side Dishes for Tomato Pie

Tomato pie will always remain that savory but straightforward meal to make your day. With some additions, you can make your tomato pie even better. Hence, there’s no reason you shouldn’t try to be creative with this dish.

1. Warm Rolls

These rolls are a classic recipe because they’re simply delicious. When it comes to serving tomato pie with these soft rolls, the combination is perfect.

What makes warm buns such an excellent accompaniment is that they’re filling without being too heavy. The warmth of the bun goes well with tomato pie, especially as the pie is best when cold. Lather them with butter to add a creamy element to the meal.

2. Baked Sweet Potato Fries

Baked sweet potato fries offer a crisp and sweet accompaniment to tomato pie. The tomato pie’s soft, cheesy texture contrasts nicely with the outer crispiness of the fries. And the sweetness of the sweet potato is the perfect partner to the cheese and tomato topping.

They’re easy to savor with a light, crispy outside and a creamy, buttery inside. Play with different seasonings like rosemary for a fantastic burst of flavor, perfect with tomato pie.

3. Green Beans

Green beans are the epitome of a healthy, classic side dish. And they offer another light option for people who want to cut down on carbs. They are filling yet not overpowering, making them the perfect side dish for any occasion. 

These delicious pods are best served sautéed in garlic butter. They’ll bring some crunch to the meal, and the garlic will complement the cheese, tomato, and oregano well. Keep a few packets of these pre-seasoned green beans frozen and reheat them whenever you need a quick meal.

4. Onion Rings

Onion rings are a great accompaniment to tomato pie if you’re looking for something savory and filling. They’re a terrific option for a comforting side dish since they’re crispy on the exterior and soft and sweet on the inside.

You can make your own by dipping rings of onion into the batter. Or you can find pre-made onion rings in the frozen foods section of your grocery store. Deep fry or bake them at a high temperature in the oven if you want them crispy and almost caramelized.

5. Macaroni and Cheese

Macaroni and cheese is always a crowd-pleaser for various occasions. And it’s a great choice when deciding what to serve with tomato pie. It’s cheesy, thick, and tasty, making it the perfect complement to the savory tomato pie.

One of the best things about this dish is that everyone loves it, and you can serve it at any time of day. Serve it at your next dinner party with your tomato pie, and your guests will go wild.

6. Broccoli Salad

Broccoli salad is an excellent option for those who prefer a sweet compliment as their side dish. It not only adds a splash of color to the table but goes well with savory foods like tomato pie.

This side dish stands out from the multitude of salads due to its uncommon ingredient combination. These include cheese, bacon, pecan nuts, red onion, and dried cranberries. The dressing comprises a mixture of mayonnaise, sour cream, and vinegar.

The sweetness of dried cranberries and pecans contrasts beautifully with the saltiness of the bacon. These flavors combine well with the tomato sauce and cheese of the tomato pie. And the combination of the soft tomato pie and crunchy broccoli salad adds to the experience.  

7. Zucchini Fritters

A light and sweet side dish is the perfect accompaniment to tomato pie. And zucchini fritters are among the most appealing options when looking for something to serve with your tomato pie.

When served with whipped cream or yogurt, these delightful little rounds are the perfect addition to your next tomato pie brunch buffet. They’re crispy on the outside and creamy on the inside. And they offer a pleasant contrast to the richness of tomato pie. Remember that overcooking zucchini fritters will remove the moisture and make them rubbery.

8. Sautéed Zucchini

Here’s another zucchini side dish that will pair perfectly with your tomato pie. Sautéed zucchini is an excellent vegetable to have on your dinner table. It’s a straightforward dish to make that pairs well with other sides, such as baked sweet potato fries or macaroni and cheese.

Sautéed zucchini incorporates a delicious blend of ingredients, including garlic and basil. This makes for a fresh and flavorful side dish to round off your meal. Zucchini is a popular ingredient in various delicious Italian dishes, from pasta to pizza. The flavors of zucchini, tomato, and cheese are an age-old beloved combination. This is why sautéed is a perfect accompaniment for your tomato pie feast.

9. Garlic and Herb Grilled Chicken Breast

This delicious garlic and herb grilled chicken breast is simple to make. The easy marinade takes just 5 minutes to make and yields tender, juicy meat that the whole family will enjoy.

You can prepare this grilled chicken in the oven or on the stovetop. Thanks to the delicious lemon, garlic, and herb marinade, the meat will taste excellent no matter how you cook it.

These marinated grilled chicken breasts are a terrific way to add protein to your tomato pie meal. The succulent chicken with its acidic and earthy marinade is a delightful contrast to the sweet tomato sauce and creamy cheese. And the meaty chicken texture paired with the soft and creamy tomato pie is utterly harmonious.

10. Pulled Pork

This pulled pork recipe draws inspiration from the renowned Mississippi pot roast. And it includes America’s beloved Ranch seasoning mix. It’s an irresistibly quick side dish, excellent for busy days when you don’t have time to tend to pull out the grill.

A pulled pork side dish includes a blend of spices and sweet barbeque basting. And it produces tender, juicy meat that simply falls apart. Top it with sweet barbeque sauce, and you have a delicious pairing for your savory tomato pie.


Now you’re armed with the best side dishes to serve with tomato pie. From crunchy vegetables to succulent meats, there’s a side dish to suit various tastes. When entertaining, combine two or three of the above side dishes for a genuinely satisfying mix of flavors. Either way, you’re guaranteed to put a smile on the faces of all your guests. And don’t be surprised when they all ask you for the recipes.