6+ Cremini Mushroom Substitutes

Cremini Mushrooms are one of the most common mushroom varieties that you can find in the supermarket. People love their rich, earthy flavor and firm texture, which goes well in pasta sauces, risottos, and many other meals.

Cremini Mushrooms are actually the same type of mushroom as White Button and Portobello Mushrooms. They’re just between the two varieties in terms of age. Sometimes, Cremini Mushrooms are called Baby Portobello or Baby Bella Mushrooms.

Cremini Mushrooms are delicious, but sometimes you can’t find them in the supermarket. In those situations, here are a few substitutions for these popular fungi.

1. White Button Mushrooms

It makes sense that White Button Mushrooms, the most common mushroom variety, function well as a substitution for Cremini Mushrooms since they are technically the same fungus. White Button Mushrooms are just picked earlier than Cremini Mushrooms. 

These mushrooms are easier to find in the supermarket and less expensive than the cremini variety so you shouldn’t have a problem finding these in the store. 

White Button Mushrooms have a milder, more neutral flavor than Cremini Mushrooms, which is a benefit if you are cooking for a picky eater who hates mushrooms, but you will miss out on some flavor. They have a floppier texture, so they do not always work as well in dishes with a lot of liquid such as soups and stews.

2. Portobello Mushrooms

A selection of uncooked raw Portobello Mushrooms

Portobello Mushrooms also work as a substitute for Cremini Mushrooms because they are the same variety of mushroom, just slightly more aged. Portobello Mushrooms have large brown caps and an aged, almost smokey flavor. They are a popular choice for vegan burgers thanks to their meaty texture.

Portobellos have a similar flavor profile to what you’d get with a cremini, although their flavor is more intense (this can be a benefit or a drawback, depending on your opinion of mushrooms in general). They are also much larger, so you may need to spend more time cutting them down to size.

3. Shiitake Mushrooms

Shiitake Mushrooms are the most popular mushroom variety in East Asia. They come in dried and fresh varieties, although the fresh kind are much more nutritious and makes for a better Cremini Mushroom substitute. 

They work well as a substitute for Cremini Mushrooms because they have a similar woodsy, almost smokey flavor.

Shiitake Mushrooms can replace Cremini Mushrooms in rice dishes, sauces, and stews. However, they have a chewier texture that some people find off-putting, particularly those who do not like mushrooms.

4. Oyster Mushrooms

Oyster Mushrooms are easily recognizable in the store thanks to their distinctive branching shape. They also have a distinctive stringy texture, which makes them a popular vegetarian replacement for pulled pork.

Oyster Mushrooms have a similar earthy flavor to creminis, making them a good substitute for sauces or side dishes. They are slightly sweeter, but that can only enhance the flavor of some dishes. The biggest drawback of this substitution is the texture, as Oyster Mushrooms are floppier than Cremini Mushrooms.

5. Eggplant

Three whole eggplants

Eggplant, a purple, oval vegetable that is a member of the nightshade family, seems like a strange substitute for Cremini Mushrooms. However, it has a similar meaty texture that allows it to function as a meat replacement, just like Cremini Mushrooms. 

The earthy flavors are also similar, although eggplant is slightly more bitter.

If you are preparing a dish for someone who does not like mushrooms, then eggplant can replace Cremini Mushrooms in risotto, stews, and pasta sauces. However, eggplant is more bitter than mushrooms so you may have to salt it beforehand to draw out some of the bitterness. It is a pretty drastic change in flavor and texture for your recipe, so be prepared for that.

6. Dried Tomatoes

If you are using Cremini Mushrooms just as a way to add flavor to a sauce or stew, then Dried Tomatoes are a great replacement. Dried Tomatoes have a similar blend of sweet and savory flavors as Cremini Mushrooms with a hint of earthiness thanks to the drying process.

To make this substitution work properly, you will need to combine dried tomatoes with herbs such as rosemary and basil. This substitution does not work in recipes where Cremini Mushrooms are a main ingredient, such as risotto.